Impress, I’m shocked that this is certainly comment #30! Hawthornehedge/Christine, In my opinion your comment towards concept of Mr. E, one to “it’s probable but not necessarily confirmed”, is pretty much according to the fundamental point I was trying to make on fanon theories typically. I am not claiming the theories We elevated getting conversation Commonly possible, just that these are typically from the sole possible interpretations away from canon. It looks some individuals believe that just because much away from fanfics otherwise fansites support a theory, one to alone was facts your idea is right. And additionally they sign on the idea also, of course “way too many almost every other fans can’t be completely wrong”, and, particularly when you are considering fanfic, is actually influences myself since the nearly sluggish.
Yards do previously give his child you to definitely he’d planned to wed another woman; I believe their “offhand feedback” idea and you will TTB’s principle he is actually idealizing his first, lost like, is actually both probable
I additionally have no idea how undoubtedly she meant for me to bring Peeta’s recollections, eleven decades later on, of something occurred as he try five years dated. Katniss herself does not apparently to start with, inquiring, “Thus, given that we had been five, that you don’t even seen any other girls? Certainly Really don’t imagine the concept one to “Mr. Yards forever cherished Mrs. Elizabeth, concise which he duped to your his wife along with her, and you can Demure was the result”, try ever before oriented! We actually do not know exactly how abusive Mrs. M actually was, or exactly how miserable Mr. M to be real within his wedding. Katniss notices one to bout of physical and you may spoken discipline, and you will Peeta references one episode of verbal abuse. Mrs. Yards also seems to have an over-all reputation since a “witch”.
M had no love for their own anyway and just injury up with their unique because of a decided relationships
But that does not mean Mr. In the real life, Many women go out, marry, and will profess undying fascination with dudes who will be abusive so you can their partners and students. They make excuses towards the punishment, and you can do select the thought of cheat on the companion repugnant. Thus, I do not pick any reason why it’s understandable one to good guy partnered to help you a keen abusive lady would gladly cheat on the, anymore than simply a lady hitched in order to an abusive man create. In terms of why Mr.
I do believe one Mr. M’s behavior is simply probable because in many abusive or unhappy marriages, moms and dads tend to move to its children, not brand new mate, for emotional support, and regularly complain concerning the partner with the kid. Mr. Yards does not really do one. However, remember that Peeta’s a reaction to their father’s confession, are “A great coal miner? As to why performed she wanted a coal miner when the she could’ve got you? As for the Seam/Merchant separate, I do believe another essential element of the newest “Prim is simply Mr. M’s youngster” idea are an expectation the Everdeens was indeed the first cross-class pair to ever before are present from inside the D12, and this there’s absolutely no ways Mr. Everdeen have got blond, blue-eyed ancestors which passed away those people family genes so you’re able to him, and whose family genes he sooner or later passed so you can datiraju s Kostarikanski damama Demure.
We re also-look at the section of THG where P and K mention you to definitely, and you can Peeta indeed does not frequently consider it had been a massive deal: “I’m sure who would excitement your mother and father, you preference a girl regarding Seam,” We state. But We wouldn’t proper care less. Anyway, if we allow it to be straight back, you simply will not getting an effective girl on the Seam, you’ll be good girl on Victor’s Town,” he says. Peeta’s mother conveyed anti-Seam bigotry whenever she tries to pursue Katniss out, and Peeta’s dad got a personal reason so you’re able to dislike individuals from brand new Seam, or at least not need their sons marrying some body following that. However, that does not mean *all* Supplier families might have thrown a match if the a baby dated or hitched out of their class, disowned them, etc.